Ninja CM401 vs Ninja CE251: Specialty Brews or a Bigger, Simpler Carafe?
Updated Jul 31, 2026 · prices refresh daily
Ninja CM401 Specialty Coffee Maker
Ninja Coffee Maker CE251
| Ninja CM401 | Ninja CE251 | |
|---|---|---|
| Brew styles | ✓ 4 - Classic, Rich, Over Ice, Specialty | 2 - Classic, Rich |
| Brew sizes | ✓ 6, from single cup to 10-cup carafe | Carafe only, up to 12 cups |
| Carafe capacity | 10-cup glass | ✓ 12-cup glass |
| Milk frother | ✓ Built-in fold-away frother | None |
| 24h delay brew | No | ✓ Yes, fully programmable |
| Warming plate | Yes | ✓ Yes, adjustable up to 4 hours |
| Pods required | No - regular grounds | No - regular grounds |
The CM401 is for people who want café-style variety, meaning iced drinks, concentrated shots and a frother; the CE251 is for people who want a big, hot, programmable pot of drip coffee and nothing else.
Ninja sells both of these as coffee makers, but they serve different mornings. The CM401 Specialty is a small brew bar with four brew styles, six sizes from a single cup to a 10-cup carafe, and a fold-away milk frother. The CE251 is a classic programmable drip machine with a 12-cup carafe, two strengths, a 24-hour delay timer and an adjustable warming plate. Neither uses pods; both take ordinary ground coffee.
What the CM401 gives you
Variety without pods. The Specialty setting pulls a concentrated brew that holds up in milk, so combined with the frother it makes a credible latte or cappuccino without an espresso machine on the counter. Over Ice brews hot directly onto ice at adjusted strength, which keeps iced coffee from tasting watered down. Because it scales from one cup to a carafe, it covers a solo weekday and a weekend table with the same machine.
What you give up is capacity and scheduling. The carafe tops out at 10 cups, and there is no delay brew; the machine starts when you press the button.
What the CE251 gives you
Simplicity at scale. Twelve cups, programmable the night before, kept hot for up to four hours on a plate you can adjust rather than scorch. Mid-brew pause works as expected. There is nothing to learn and little to clean. If your household drinks a lot of plain hot drip coffee, this is the sensible design.
What you give up is range. There are no single-cup sizes, no iced mode and no frother, and none of that can be added later.
At today’s prices
As of August 2026 both sides are in the tracker with young histories. The CM401 has live store rows and is currently out of stock at the maker’s store. The CE251 appears only as labeled open-box stock, because it has left production. Verdicts land after 30 days of recorded history, so neither side carries an urgency claim yet. The structural point survives the discontinuation: the CE251 platform was always the cheaper route to plain drip, a role its CE451 successor now inherits, and the CM401 premium buys the Specialty mode, the frother and the size flexibility rather than better basic drip.
The honest bottom line
Buy the CM401 if iced drinks, milk drinks or one-cup brewing appear anywhere in your week, because that is what the premium pays for. Buy the CE251 route, through labeled open-box stock or the CE451, if coffee means a big hot pot ready when you wake. Paying for features you will not press is how kitchen machines end up unloved.
Some links on this page may earn us a commission. This never affects prices, rankings or verdicts.Full disclosure